2012 Ferrari 458 4.5 Italia

Price: £199,950. Fair price: £13,206 (7%) over the AskCar estimate of £186,744, our expected asking price for this car from its model, age, mileage and specification, drawing on 51 priced Ferrari 458 adverts on AskCar as of 2 November 2026.

AskCar lists 71 used Ferrari 458 from 53 UK dealerships, as of 2 November 2026.

Overview

  • Make: Ferrari
  • Model: 458
  • Trim: Italia
  • Version: 4.5 Italia Auto RWD Euro 5 2dr (562 bhp)
  • Year: 2012
  • Mileage: 29,874 miles
  • Fuel: Petrol
  • Body: Coupe, 2 doors, 2 seats
  • Engine: 4.5 litres, 562 bhp
  • Gearbox: Automatic
  • Drive: Rear-wheel drive
  • Colour: Silver
  • CO2: 307 g/km
  • Emissions standard: Euro 5, ULEZ compliant

About this car

This 2012 Ferrari 458 Italia has covered 29,874 miles, around 9,900 more miles than is typical for its age. The AskCar estimate for this car is £186,744. It is priced at £199,950, which is £13,206 above that estimate. The AskCar estimate draws on 51 Ferrari 458 adverts across the UK, adjusting for age, mileage, trim, engine and other specifications. We have tracked this advert for 60 days. The seller is Mayfair Prestige UK, based in City of Westminster. How to contact the dealer and its opening hours are on this AskCar page.

Stock data as of 2 November 2026.

How we estimate prices and check cars

Price

Fair price: £13,206 (7%) over the AskCar estimate of £186,744.

The AskCar estimate is our expected asking price for this car. It uses UK dealer asking prices, accounting for make, model, trim, version, age, mileage, fuel, gearbox, body type, driven wheels, engine size and power. It is an advertised price, not a confirmed sale price.

It draws on 51 priced Ferrari 458 adverts across different ages and specifications, as of 2 November 2026.

A 2012 Ferrari 458 with the 4.5 petrol engine is typically advertised at £204,600: the median of the 17 for sale on AskCar, as of 2 November 2026.

Time on sale

This 2012 Ferrari 458 has been on sale for at least 60 days.

Price history

AskCar first saw this advert on 3 September 2026 at £199,950. Its asking price has not changed.

Mileage and MOT

Advertised mileage is about 9,900 miles higher than the median mileage of a 2012 Ferrari 458 on AskCar.

Similar cars

10 other 2012 Ferrari 458 Italia 4.5 petrol automatic coupes are for sale at UK dealers, from £139,999 to £214,950, as of 2 November 2026.

The 3 closest to this car in mileage:

  • 2012 Ferrari 458 Italia, 4.5 petrol coupe, black. Mileage: 28,500 miles. Price: £189,990, £9,960 less than this car. Dealer: Simon Furlonger Specialist Cars Ashford Showroom in Ashford. AskCar page: https://askcar.co.uk/car/ferrari-458-2012-edfd60e8dc50
  • 2012 Ferrari 458 Italia, 4.5 petrol coupe, red. Mileage: 36,239 miles. Price: £169,950, £30,000 less than this car. Dealer: Mayfair Prestige UK in City of Westminster. AskCar page: https://askcar.co.uk/car/ferrari-458-2012-d7ec52c40397
  • 2012 Ferrari 458 Italia, 4.5 petrol coupe, red. Mileage: 22,000 miles. Price: £204,600, £4,650 more than this car. Dealer: JCT600 Approved Leeds in Leeds. AskCar page: https://askcar.co.uk/car/ferrari-458-2012-b1dc4fb529a2

Browse all Ferrari 458 cars for sale · 2012 Ferrari 458 price guide

More like this

Photos

42 photos of this car are on its AskCar page.

As of 2 November 2026, AskCar lists 586,270 cars and vans from 12,920 UK dealerships, read daily from dealer websites: over 99% of UK dealer used car adverts. No dealer pays to be listed.